Satish Naik, Vitla/Dubaii

The real rebel till in BJP. First get him ( renukacharya) out from the party . he is working like Narada muni.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

anil, bangalore

Karnataka Governor asks CM to prove majority again

Karnataka Governor H R Bhardwaj on Tuesday asked chief minister B S Yeddyurappa to prove majority on the floor of the House afresh by October 14.
BANGALORE: Karnataka Governor H R Bhardwaj on Tuesday wrote to chief minister Yeddyurappa giving him another chance to prove majority in second floor test.

Governor H R Bhardwaj has set October 14 as deadline for second floor test.

Read more: Karnataka Governor sets Oct 14 as deadline for second floor test - The Times of India http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/Karnataka-Governor-sets-Oct-14-as-deadline-for-second-floor-test/articleshow/6734816.cms#ixzz1281IOhcY

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

M.bhat, Mumbai

Congress has hit the nail on its own head by this misadventure along with "APPA Magana" party. Its shame that we have governer who is not impartial, working overtly as congress agent and has been invloved in destabilishing the democratically elected Governemnt. This chap has dragged the constitutional office into controversy and disrepute. Give him one way tickt to Delhi. People will teach congress a lesson if elections are held.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ronald D, Udupi

Mahendra Shetty, operation Kamala was performed without paying money? Reddy's illegal mining is legal? Coastal highways of Karnataka were not damaged by Reddy's illeagal ore transport? Most politicians of Karnataka are corrupt and greedy for power. Why take sides? Track record says Congress is slightly better! Under their rule corruption was less compared to what we see today!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Thomas, Mlore, Blore

What Majority u guys are talkin about. Mnc's support was been counted by the speaker who was taking the side of BJP. The Corruption has reached so much now they are shit scared so the next gove will bring out the corruption made by them to the media hence they need to keep their seats intact. Since we have a very good governor who they are planning to chase them out and proven his abitility by giving them a second chance.This is that what happens when the govt is formed by paying money to MLA's they dont last long and this is what happend here too.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

MANISH KUMAR, mangalore

THIS IS ALL BECAUSE OF KUMARASWAMY AND 17 SHAMELESS AND GREEDY MLA ALL PROBLEMS STARTED FROM THEM.IF PEOPLE GAVE MAJORITY TO BJP TO RULE THEN WHY THEY ARE PLAYING CHEAP POLITICS. WE SHOULD WAIT FIVE YEARS THEN ELECTION TIME IF WE DONT LIKE THIS RULE WE CAN VOTE OTHERS. BUT ANYBODY CAME TO POWER THE PROBLEM DOES NOT ENDED.98%POLITICIANS WANTS POWER AND MONEY.THAT IS BETTER NOT TO VOTE ANYBODY.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

prem, kadri

mr. shoukat hussain...It is clearly evident that congress & JDS are the who are fustrated...and at any cost want to put down BJP.
Do you remember any development done for the welfare of the people by Congresss...
People of Karnataka have stopped making blundres, the best example is showing their rejection towards congress, by not electing them...n i hope this will continue.....Jai hoo...Jai BJP

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

lukas, malpe

Governor mr, bharadvaj is good gentle man when he was in politics not like our minister.this lesson for the all indipendent candidate who is support for the BJP in future.there is 20% muslim and christian in state but for the suvrival of the government they removed one muslim minster in cabinet. this government should go as early as posible for the unity of the state, in future jd(s)and congress should join together to wipe out this goverment from south india like maharastra

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

mahendra shetty, mumbai,dubai

Mr.Surendra Shetty Kinnigoli Nigeria,according to u BJP is a communal,corrupt,but what about JD s and Congress?? Recently Siddaramayya met Kumaraswamy and planned this Conspiracy.Rebels kept in Goa,paid Cores of Money,for each MLA its cost 30 Crores.I don't blame JD s because Gowda and Family most corrupted Political Family in this Country.Congress knows in Karnataka their chance of winning Election is very less,in recent bye election,muncipal election people gave verdict,that's why they planned back door entry,shame on Congress.

This plan was directed by Agent of Congress Bharadwaj.what we expect from Bharadwaj,the guy who defended Qutrochi,...but one thing i will tell you whatever happens PRESIDENT RULE) now onwards it good for BJP.Karnataka people know the game of Congress and JD S....SATYAMEVA JAYATE.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Sudhir, Mangaluru

Surendar Shetty, Who said BJP doent have majority. See the calculation below
Total Seats 225
Speaker 1
Disqualified 16
So now total Seats 208
To have majority BJP should have 104
NOW BJP IS HAVING 105 which is clear majority.

My qtn :
1. On what basis governor said 120 MLA are against government?
2. How can central government impose president rule when BJP having majority.
3. Speaker decesion can be questioned only bu High court not any governor.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Shoukath Hussain, Surathkal/Dubai

It is clearly evident that Yeddy is desperately obsessed with his seat and power. He did it openly and managed to retain his seat thru unlawful means and nefarious practices. Do you all think that he is interested in the welfare of the people ? He conducts meetings in luxury resorts, takes his ministers on foreign trips on govt cost, now wants to take them to Delhi by chartered flight. Has been desperately visiting temples and donating huge amounts of tax payers' money to mutts and temples.

Do we really need such a fanatic chief minister for a civilized Karnataka state ? Even though he managed to survive at the moment, we don't think people will never make the blunder of electing the BJP government once again in the next election. He clearly and surely knows that this is his last chance and so he is trying to do his best now because it will be "now or never" for him.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Charles D'Mello, Pangala

These guy's do not deserve political power ! They deserve 11 KV Electrical Power..!!

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

lukas, malpe

shame on Mr, yeudirappa,our state assembly become like bihar,too much corruption by the ministers.I never seen any CM did before for the sake of his chair

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Tony Pinto, Manglore - Dubai

Surendra Shetty, Kinnigoli/Nigeria good thoughts but my question why our coastal side Congress heavy weight MLA are silence on entire episode why not screaming reason if BJP falls it will become more powerful in coastal side and rest of KARNATAKA congress will be ground zero , even Yeddi required the same to get rid of REDDY BROTHER etc etc what you think Yeddi is fool in politics no one cares for public once tasted power need the same at any cost.BJP may adopt new step if they want they are supporting TELEGANA same formula will be given to TULUNADU just wait & See the dirty politics played. we are just burning our blood staying aboard & commuting

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Dev, Mangalore

It seems the real opposition party in Karnataka is only JDS, though it has 28 mla's it brought down to knees the ruling party(it almost dethroned BJP). Kumaraswamy has guts to tread the path nobody else seems to dare. He is better equipped to rule Karnatka for 5 years. If there is a saner element in all these drama then it must me him only. Yeddi lost all the sympathy he had by clinging on to power(chair) by sham vote, if only he had resigned & paved way for a more able less tainted, young leader then his name would have been ever green like R. Hegde for going to people when all these political farce took place. But to expect all these from todays politicians is like day dreaming & misfortune of todays voters, without having any other alternative.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Surendra Shetty, Kinnigoli/Nigeria

I saw the full epoisode & counter discussions & arguments. CM wants to parade 105 MLAS . This figure is below majority & this parade will only prove he has no majority. Can not understand why all this? Conclusion is very simple. CM has lost the simple majority & he must resign with respect & dignity . He has used wicked method to win. He has disqualified the Independent MLAS which he has no right & is against democarcy. I do not know whatever Kumar & Cong has done is correct or not but there was no other way than doing that as Govt was totally corrupt & was a communal type Govt & was proceeding without control.Ganhijis dream was communalfree india & we must fight for this cause .Communalism is the worst sickness of india

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Jossey Saldanha, Kemmennu

If you go by the rule book he has no business disqualifying 5 independent MLA’s. The greed for power and lust for the CM’s chair has made this guy a despot. Dr. V. S. Acharya, kindly get this guy treated at some Neuropsychiatric centre asap.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Wilson Dsouza, Paladka

Whether the decision of the speaker is good or bad, the speaker has shown door to the dissidents who are always blackmailing the govt staying in resort. The role of dissidents can't be justified. This type of dissidency has always been a threat to democracy and blackmailed many govts on previous occasions. This should be stopped somehow. Only stern action by the speaker can stop this ...

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Valson Mendonsa, Mangalore/USA

NEWS:BJP to Parade 105 MLAs Before Rashtrapathi Bhavan on October 12?
Is it true or BJP like make jokes for themself.. there is no political parties in the world able to fool permanently to the general public...if they do.. they will loose thier political milage permanently for sure!! what they do now thatz good for the future for other parties.. All matter of time..

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Deshpremi, Mumbai

Kumaraswamy might have thought of getting elected as the CM and then reaping the Benefit of High Iron ore prices and make lot of money.All Politicians are Corrupt but amongst the Lot BJP appears to be least Corrupt and hence people have voted them to power

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Ronald Mathias, Mangalore / Bahrain

TSUNAMI..!!! in the Karnataka State Politics...?

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Suresh Heggade, Nairobi

The shameless BJP after murdering democracy and raping Anti-Defection law, now you want to go to Delhi? You do not know the basic artithmetic? You are having only 105 MLAs against required minimum of 113, whom you want to add? Is it Reddy, Somanna, Vijayashankar, etc? They are MLCs and are not accepted for counting to prove the trust vote. Please be in your house and watch any good news channels to hear that good news i.e., your govt is dismissed.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

RAJESH, MANGALORE/DUBAI

BJP ke dono ungly ghee me hai ab.BJP will emerge more strongly hereafter as all the kachras are out.cong and JDS is like na ghar ke na ghaat ke..jai bjp jai hind

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Nitesh R.M, Mangalore

Dont worry Yeddi the President will NOT DISSOLVE your incompetent government. You will rule for another 2.5 years with your 105 clowns well short of the majority and still continue to loot the state .

And one day when people get fed up they will kick you,your Operation Kamala out and your arrogance OUT!!

SATYAMEVA JAYATE!!

Could we get some upda

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

KT, Mangalore

Just watched some clipping of the assembly, shame on those policeman and marshals, some of the minister are beating policeman and marshal and they are kept quite like woman. If a common man the policeman moustache will go up and he beats him to death. Police man shame on you. You all are like prostitutes.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

PRADEEP, MANGALORE

BJP has played the game of politics as played by the opposition. Gowda and his sons greatest curse to karnataka politics are made to bite their own pill. Hats off to Yeddy & gang. I wish they will continue for the full term without evil forces stalking them.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Vijay Shetty Gulvady, Dubai

I think Mr. Louis D'Souza/Udupi has lost the mental balance after Yeddyurappa's win. If Yeddyurappa is having 105, how Cong JDS Independents rebels can be 120? I think Governor counted his secretary and himself also. 16 MLAs are already disqualified and only the court can decide whether they need to be counted or not.
I also wonder why all people are questioning the presence of Renukacharya with CM? Was he good when with HDK's rebel camp. Mr. Louis thinks it's easy for President to take the decision, joke of the day...........HA HA HA.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

shahnawaz kukkikatte, dubai/udupi

Allthe DW readers - Do we really need to be governed by these fools, donkeys, monkey, unethical and moraleless dirty souls?????? We are better off during British Raj. Where is the flood relief gone, just to buy these MLAs? Where is the booty from Bellary gone? The common man is deprived of his basic rights that is a decent living, decent shelter and and decent food. These dirty souls have lots of public and tax payers money to spend in hotels, charter planes, drinks and on women. Is it the standard of our state? Is it the status of our home state? Disgusting. Please say no to all and let there be for some time Prez rule in ouur state. Let each party do the introspection and wait and mend themselves. We certainly dont need one more election, at the same time we dont need corrupt and unethical government. We want a simple and just government which works for the people of our state. I dont trust Congress, JDS or BJP. Now I have started feeling shame and guilty of calling myself as son of Kannada mathe. I call upon the sincere sons of karnataka to reject all govt formed out of money power and go in for Prez rule. What a shame. Nowhere in other states this type of shameless activities are happening. Disgusting to see Ananthkumar, who masterminded whole drama, smiling and artificially celebrating the victory. I prefer to be governed by outlaws than these thugs with dirty souls.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Gireesh Shetty, Sharjah-mangalore

Dear Yeddi, the whole state knows your hidden agenda. I guess you you would be more than happy if presidents rule is implemented coz you do not have any other reason next time while going to people for votes. Your scams have erased the feel of any good works you might have done. I guess you are challenging Devegowda in playing mindgames in politics.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Mohammed Ilyas, Byndoor/Dubai UAE

AFTER HONEYMOON BY 20 MINISTER'S AT LAST TRYING TO SETTLE DOWN WITH BJP?

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Joseph D'souza, Mangalore / Dubai

This is useless. Becuase tomorrow highcourt is going to put the stay on disqualification. So, they should have 113 not 103. These brainless stupid leaders disqualified the Ind. MLA's. How they can do so?

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Arun CK, Managlore- Dubai

Dear Yeddi
No use now, President is nothing but another Bharadwaj but sitting in Delhi. Its all set.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

KT, Mangalore

We all say corrupt politician now you we have corrupt governor also. Mr. Bhardwaj, as a Governor don't have any power to dictate Speaker of the house. Mr. Bhardwaj, has crossed the limit as a governor being a ceremonial head of the state. He did send a FBI agent to England to defreege the bank account of Quattrocci, an Italian friend of Sonia Gandhi when he was law minister in UPA Govt, so that the Bofors scandal money can be taken away by this Sonia friend. Due to that unethical act , he lost the minister's job in the center. Now, as a Cong(I) agent he want to do it again in Karnataka. People of Karnataka and the country won't allow these dirty tricks.
Gowdas the money hungry people desperate to have the CM seat at least for few days / few hours so that their paper work can be pushed forward get sanction for some of their relative’s project.

Disgrace Karnataka

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Kishore, India

Wait and watch, the BJP will become splinter groupa after President rule. One will be Ananth Kumar group, the second Yeddyurappa group, third Reddy group, fourth Renukacharya group, etc.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait

BSY is making fool of himself, lost his mental balance. Take Shanker Bidari and few MLCs so that the no. may reach 113.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Louis D'Souza, Udupi/Kuwait

BSY will parade MLAs like Renukacharya in front Rashtrapathi Bhavan? Any way good move, he himself will prove that he has just 105 and is short of majority. Cong, JDS has 120 MLAs. Easy for the president to take dicision. So sad to see Renukacharya along with BSY.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Prem, Mangalore

Can any one tell me who teached Maths subject for these persons, they dont have a common sense that they need 113 MLA to prove their Majority and not 105. As some are disqualified and surely court will stay speaker order then what BJP is trying to prove by parading 105 MLA god only knows.........

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

KT, Mangalore

I don’t think Chidambaram and Antony (Back bone of Congress) will force governor to dissolve the assembly, they know by doing that Congress will loose its credibility. If they are smart let them allow BJP to complete the term and stay away from Gowdas. Cong has some from JDS , get them out and launch young and honest (if available) candidate

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

anis ahmed, mangalore/dubai/agc

DEAR CONGRESS PLS DISMISS BJP GOVT. SO IT WILL HELP BJP TO GET SYMPATHY AND HELP TO RETURN TO POWER WITH OWN MAJORITY. THANKS TO THE OLD FOOL WHO IS HELPING FOR THIS.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

ISMAIL K PERINJE, PERINJE/YANBU-KSA

IT IS NOW CERTAIN THAT YEEDY SMELLING PRESIDENT RULE /ASSEMBLY SUSPENDED ANIMATION AS MEDIA ,POLITICAL,CONSTITUTIONAL AND FINALLY VOTERS ARE IN FAVOR OF A FINAL "NO" FOR BJP's CORRUPTION,SWAJANAPAKSHA PATHA FROM CM HIMSELF TO BE PUT IN TO REST PERMENANTLY.THIS ALL DRAMA ENACTED BY YEDDY TO DIVERT THE ATTENTION OF PUBLIC FROM HIS OWN SCANDAL OF DENOTIFICATION.THIS A CONSPIRACY AGAINST HIS AND GANG'S MISMANAGEMENT IN KARNATAKA STATE.BOTH YEDDY AND REDDY'S GANG SHOULD BE PROSCUTED.PARADING MLA's AND MPs ARE OF CHAALI OF BJP.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

KT, Mangalore

Partial victory of BJP has welcomed very well by Mangalore real estate lobby, BJP candidates who brought plot around MCC development plan going to announce mega project soon.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

Balakrishna Shetty, Yellur/Dubai

Kar Natak and Karte Raho Natak. Yeddy would be leading the Donkeys parade. Undoubtedly the men of straw are in power and they must go to save the Indian democratic value if any left.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

rizwan, Dubai/Mangalore

Friends, just name one HONEST political face in the above photographs .... We know there is none. Bharath Matha ki jai.

DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse