Three disqualified MLAs to appeal against Speaker's order


Bengaluru, Jul 27 (IANS): Karnataka's three disqualified legislators, including two rebel Congress MLAs, would on Monday move the Supreme Court and the Karnataka High Court against the Speaker's order, sources said on Saturday.

The disqualified legislators are Ramesh Jarkiholi and Mahesh Kumatahalli of the Congress and R. Shankar of the KPJP, whom the Congress claims to have merged his regional outfit with it on June 14 after he became minister again in the then JD-S-Congress coalition government.

"As petitions of Jarkiholi and Kumatahalli against Speaker K.R. Ramesh Kumar are in the apex court since July 10, they would file affidavits against their unilateral disqualification without serving notice or giving them an opportunity to defend themselves," a source told IANS quoting the rebels, who are under lockdown in a Mumbai star hotel since July 6.


Disqualified Karnataka MLAs (from left) Ramesh Jarakiholi, Mahesh Kumathalli and R Shankar

Shankar, who won from Ranebannur in the May 2018 assembly elections, floated the Karnataka Pragnyavanthara Janatha Paksha (KPJP) after leaving the Congress for denying him ticket to contest.

"Pledging support to the BJP in writing to Governor Vajubhai Vala on July 8 after resigning as Minister on the same day and withdrawing support to the coalition government does not amount to defection and the anti-defection law cannot be applied to disqualify him," the source claimed.

Shankar will file his writ petition against the Speaker's order in the Karnataka High Court on Monday.

Citing the case of 18 AIADMK legislators, who were disqualified in September 2017, but allowed by the apex court and the Election Commission to contest the by-elections in six months, the source said the Speaker has "erred" in banning the rebels from contesting any election for the rest of the Assembly's term - till 2023.

Jarkiholi and Kumatahalli were disqualified on a complaint by Congress Legislature Party leader Siddaramaiah on February 11 for not "attending" the 10-day budget session from February 7-20 and two legislature party meetings held on January 18 and February 7, despite the party whip.

"Assembly records, however, show that Jarkiholi and Kumathalli attended the session on February 14-15 and voted on the budget proposals for fiscal 2019-20, which was a vote-on-account for four months till July 31," the source said.

According to former Advocate-General and constitutional law expert B.V. Acharya, the Speaker's decision to disqualify the three MLAs was wrong and misconceived, and would not pass judicial scrutiny

"The disqualification is against the constitutional provisions and the well-accepted principles of law," Acharya had told local news channels, adding that the reasons for disqualifying them do not come under the provisions of the anti-defection law.

However, the Speaker, announcing the disqualifications on Thursday, had said that the "resignations are neither voluntary nor genuine but given under duress or pressure".

Disagreeing with the Speaker's reasons, Acharya said: "The disqualifications are contrary to the Supreme Courts judgements in similar cases and amount to its contempt."

Terming the Speaker's decision one-sided, bad in law and arbitrary, BJP spokesman G. Madhusudan told IANS on Saturday the apex court, in its interim orders on July 17, had said that the Speaker's ruling on the resignations would have to be placed before it for scrutiny.

"As the disqualifications are not in conformity with the anti-defection law and are based on extraneous reasons, I am afraid they will not be upheld by the courts," he added.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Vincent Rodrigues, Katapadi/Bangaluru

    Sun, Jul 28 2019

    Hope our elected members really work for those who elected them than their own interest.

    DisAgree Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • SmR, Karkala

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    The scourge of defections groomed by BJP for the sake of clinging to power without any ballot using money, muscle, and administrative power has developed into a “raging contagious disease”.

    The MLAs are being bought in broad daylight, democracy is being denigrated in broad daylight. The constitution is being trampled upon in broad daylight in Karnataka. The Karnataka MLAs obviously did not have ethics on their mind. No one was in doubt that their motive was to see the back of the government they were part of and cross over to the BJP side whenever the by-elections to the seats vacated by them are held. Ethics were not a consideration for the BJP either. Nor BJP has any respect for voters mandate.

    The culture of defections Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram has now attained a new definition in India. The new word for Aaya Ram Gaya Ram is Modi - mischievously orchestrated defections in India. BJP has started this culture of defections and `Aaya ram Gaya ram' in as many as 12 states of the country. The Karnataka will be the 13th state BJP in ruling by illicit means.

    In Manipur High Court raped the speaker for not disqualifying Congress MLA who defected to BJP.
    Though Congress was the single largest party with 28 seats, it fell three seats short of the required number to achieve a simple majority in the 60-member assembly. The BJP, with 21 seats, stitched up an alliance with three regional parties, thus taking its tally to 30 seats. This was still one short of the majority mark. Shyamkumar Singh’s who elected from Congress without resigning defected to the BJP thus helped the party form a coalition government. Later six more MLA's joined when the assembly is in session, they don’t sit in the treasury benches, but with the opposition – just to avoid the anti-defection law.
    The Karnataka Speaker is right in his decision. Perhaps Supreme Court intervention is wrong.
    Now BJP wants Manipur in Karnataka. In Manipur defected MLA's even voted for lone Rajya Sabha seats and many bills.
    JH

    DisAgree [5] Agree [10] Reply Report Abuse

  • Kumar, Bengaluru

    Sun, Jul 28 2019

    Have you read the article.

    Jarkiholi and Kumatahalli were disqualified on a complaint by Congress Legislature Party leader Siddaramaiah on February 11 for not "attending" the 10-day budget session from February 7-20 and two legislature party meetings held on January 18 and February 7, despite the party whip.

    "Assembly records, however, show that Jarkiholi and Kumathalli attended the session on February 14-15 and voted on the budget proposals for fiscal 2019-20, which was a vote-on-account for four months till July 31," the source said.

    SC will consider the Assembly records and declare the Speaker's decision as arbitrary and illegal.

    DisAgree [3] Agree [2] Reply Report Abuse

  • ad, mangaluru

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    Looks like SC is running the country. No need of any other mechanisms.

    DisAgree Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse

  • Karan, Katapadi/Dubai

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    They will join BJP, so, next time they can win through EVM machine.... no need of public votes.

    DisAgree [5] Agree [32] Reply Report Abuse

  • Philip, Manglore

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    They should throw in dustbin.they have cheat the people of there place.they won bcoz of Congress not bcoz of bjp

    DisAgree Agree [17] Reply Report Abuse

  • Dhanalaxmi VAN, Bajpe

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    They can buy expensive lawyers
    But not justice !

    DisAgree Agree [26] Reply Report Abuse

  • David Pais, Mangalore

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    demonetised black money fed enough 2 rebels.

    DisAgree Agree [28] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jossey Saldanha, Nashville

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    Black Money is the Culprit ...

    DisAgree [4] Agree [33] Reply Report Abuse

  • Deva, Pilar

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    Dirty Politics ..they don't care who voted them.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [45] Reply Report Abuse

  • Mr Clean, Mangalore

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    Holding the MLAs in lockdown in Mumbai with police watch and at gun point without outside communication by BJP is also anti democratic. MLAs should have been free and attending the assembly as and when needed. But this is with threat and forced defection by BJP.

    DisAgree [1] Agree [30] Reply Report Abuse

  • Jogesh, Pilar

    Sat, Jul 27 2019

    They all win soon and will be assigned cabinet ministry. For Ramesh Jharkoli is sure.

    DisAgree [31] Agree [9] Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: Three disqualified MLAs to appeal against Speaker's order



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.