I did'nt Switch Loyalties for Monetory Considerations - Manorama


I did'nt switch loyalties for monetory considerations - Manorama
Daijiworld Media Network - Udupi (SP)

Udupi, Jul 24: Speaking to reporters here on Wednesday July 23, Udupi MP Manorama Madhwaraj said, that she did not receive money for abstaining from voting during the trust vote and that she was ready to swear to this effect even at Dharmastala temple. I am ever prepared for any kind of inquiry into the alleged deal, she declared.

She said, union minister Oscar Fernandes had requested her to vote in favour of the trust vote. My prolonged fight against the coal based Nagarjuna project did not receive support from the BJP leaders. I support the nuclear power plants to coal based ones because of the health hazards the latter pose. However, I did not vote for the UPA as Congress leaders too did not lend me support for my anti-Nagarjuna crusade, she clarified. Asked about the chances of shiftingback to Congress, she said she was not in favour of making any predictions about her future plans at this juncture. On the question of resigning from the Lok Sabha, she said that the voters had elevated her to this position although BJP had given her the ticket. I will resign only if my voters ask me to do so, she announced.

Manorama, a four time legislator representing Congress party(1972, 1978, 1985 and 1989) and who was given the post of a state minister thrice (1972, 1978 and 1989), also functioned as the chairperson of the Tourism Development Corporation, a post equivelant to that of a minister, decided to leave her parent party in the year 2004 and became a member of parliament in the same year after joining BJP. Now, by acting against the whip issued by BJP, she has revolted against the party and in a knee-jerk reaction, BJP has expelled her for choosing to abstain from voting in the trust vote.

After her husband Madhwaraj became a Congress MLA in 1962, Manorama continued to fight all the elections from Udupi constituency since 1972, before she was defeated by U R Sabhapathi, a candidate of Karnataka Kranti Ranga in 1994. In the next assembly election, Sabhapathi contested as a Congress candidate and became MLA. Manorama was defeated by Dr V S Acharya, BJP candidate once and U R Sabhapathi another time.

Manorama, who donned the role of state minister longer than anyone else from the district, found herself marginalised in Congressafter U R Sabhapathi emerged as a viable candidate in Udupi constituency. Even though chief minister S M Krishna gave her the chance to head the Tourism Devement Corporation, Congress was unwilling to give her a ticket for the Lok Sabha election. BJP found in her a suitable candidate to represent backward castes,but she somehow could not carve out a niche for herself in that party and Nagarjuna issue acted as a catalyst for her souring relationship with BJP.

It may be recalled however, that permission to set up Jesco Steel Plant, the predecessor of Nagarjuna Power Plant,at Tokur was given by Manorama. This was the first ever private power project cleared by the then state cabinet headed by Veerappa Moily. While Manorama has become the bete noire of Nagarjuna project now, Moily has not expressed opposition to it so far.

When Manorama became the BJP candidate from Udupi parliamentary constituency, her son Pramod Madhwaraj fought the election as the Congress candidate from Brahmavar assembly constituency. In the recent assemby election, Pramod again fought as the Congress candidate, but Manorama stayed away from canvassing for the BJP candidate. Although she cited her sore eyes as the reason for not taking active role in the electioneering, it caused lot of heart burn in the BJP camp.

Out of the three state MPs who acted against the whip issued by their parent party BJP, Manorama alone chose to abstain from voting. Kodgi, the erstwhile Congres colleague of Manorama who was instrumental in wooing her into the BJP fold, perhaps got scent of her dubious loyalties. For convincing her to vote against the trust vote, he went to New Delhi and stayed there to press her not to do so but failed. Her son Pramod too was in Delhi and he might have played a role in convincing her to support the survival of the UPA.

There were reports that Manorama, while coming back from Delhi, was accompanied by a strong police contigent from Bajpe airport and that she chose to ride alongwith her son Pramod in his car instead of the MP's car. Manorama has now expressed her willingness to face any disciplinary action that the party might initiate against her and also her decision not to contest for Lok Sabha seat again. She has also rejected the police security, provided at her residence in anticipation of retaliation by BJP supporters.

While the BJP is gearing up to stage a protest against Manorama, Congress district committee president M A Gafoor said that his party is ready to welcome her into its fold. The fact that she is toeing the congress line of thinking that nuclear power projects are indispensable for the country, we welcome her into the party, he said. Meanwhile, BJP, which has alleged that she supported the UPA in return for monetory gains, belying BJP's trust in her that she was a person with clean hands, has organised a protest meeting near Udupi bus stand at 4 pm today. The BJP workers have alleged that she was treated with respect in the party although she used to degrade and deride party leaders and workers. They complain, that she did not respond to the problems of the people as expected from a MP. Protests are planned in other constituencies in the district too. If she does not resign from her Lok Sabha membership, BJP workers will organise protests in front her residence too, party activists have warned.

  

Top Stories

Comment on this article

  • Sachidananda Kanchan, Mangalore / Qatar

    Sat, Jul 26 2008

    Good that Mr. Conald j baptist has not recommended Mrs. Madhwaraj for "Bharat Ratna"!!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Sat, Jul 26 2008

    Dear Margaret, this is the beginning, 123 agreement is in favour of poor. This is the first step towards poor. Somebody has to begin somewhere, give her some more time.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rakesh S, Manipal

    Sat, Jul 26 2008

    Exactly Margaret. What has Manorama done for the people of Udupi till now?? Now, when the greedy lady knows that she stands nowhere within BJP, she does this cunning act to switch over to Congress... When educated people themselves blindly appreciate Manorama, its no surprise that the common folks voted her to power last time.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Margaret, Udupi/dubai

    Sat, Jul 26 2008

    I know Mrs.Madhwaraj since I was a child. but till today I have not seen she is doing something good to poor people of Udupi. Is she really a politician???or just she wants the name in society?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • rajesh ramachandra, Urwa Mangalore/ Dubai

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    I read all the coments on this mail the one thing I do not understand why the people appreciate Monorama voted aginst BJP for the nuclear deal and how many of them know about the nuclear 123 agreement and its hidden agenda.This is my personal opinion I do not want our future generation face all the problem of eliminating the waste generate from nuclear power station.this is example france had 56 nuclear power stations producing 73% of the country,s total power requirement they are catching up the problem of eliminating the wastes/emissions from out of those plant at the same. now they thinking how to reduce the power consumption in the country. we have lots of other source to produce powere and also we have lots of technology in our country.

    I have lots of respect for Mr. APJ Abudual Kalam I realy do not know why is supporting this deal. regarding the monoroma people of Udupi as decide becuase they voted and also voted for BJP. I am only worried about nuclear deal with USA I cannot trust any of the politician in our country and I belive 95% of citizen do not know what is deal. I would be grateful, if the young generation wake up and make debate on this matter becuase country is now in your hand. Jai Hind " God Bless our country"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ranganath, Udupi

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    Can anybody tell what she has done for Udupi so far.There are burning problems like deaths in NH-17 ,Naxalites etc, she has never attempted to do anything on them.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Wilson D`Souza, Paladka

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    Thanks Manorama. At least people like you showed that you can open your conscience even though there is party whip. Beauty of Indian democracy is hidden inside people like you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vishal, USA

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    I usually supports BJP politically. But in this case BJP is totally wrong. I really admire Manorama for her decision not to vote against the government, also it stopped from country's worst politician like Mayavathi to become Prime Minister of India.

    For me that was more scarrier than not to have nuclear deal. India needs nuclear energy to overcome the power outage, also it reduces the pollution level as well. I think nuclear energy little less expensive compared to wind,water or solar which is again,can be debatable.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • A.D'Cunha Shenoy, mangaluru

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    I think all radioactive waste must be dumped in her backyard, then only will she know what nuclear energy is. what loyalty she is talking about?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Nurya, Bangalore

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    Well done Mrs. Madwaraj, in India we need people like you who are strong, brave and faithful working for the country and not for just for power in the government to ruin the nation.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Two wrongs cannot make one right. Similarly two rights also cannot make one wrong. She has not changed her party as she has been elected from her constituency for that party (one right). Secondly although she was in favour of the 123 agreement, she did not vote in favour of the ruling party to save the government as she belongs to BJP (Second right) which eventually saved the government and saved the tax payers money, which would have been wasted for the early election.

    I don’t agree with anyone that staying neutral is wrong. Everyone should have the freedom to express their view and support what is good for India and for the people of India. Come-on gentlemen, we are not living in former USSR or in China.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Roshan Pais, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    First of all I salute you Manorama. For all others( sanctimonious or not) just this: so What? Changing the party is nothing. We Indians are cleaver in mudslinging.. She honestly believes in what she does. Our parties are not saints and one has to show true grit to survive.

    Being a lady and a mature person - we need more likes of her for our country to advance . We dont need people like ADvani who bring shame to India.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rizwan, Ullal, Duabi

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    You have done the great job. Keep it up!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Gautam, Udupi

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Goodness me! people are so stupid even now not to understand Manorama's wicked plots, that they are even complimenting her ??? She's such a disgrace to either party... What has she done to Udupi during her entire tenure as MLA as well as MP???

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • kaibrahim, MULKI

    Fri, Jul 25 2008

    You have done according to your conscience. But people have realised that you are an opportunist. But anything you are doing please do for the sake of people of our constuitency.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bharathi, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Manorama you are an expert politician and good in playing politics. I think you have not got the suitacase from Nagarjuna so you are against Nagarjuna and got a big suitcase from your good old friends ?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • SURESH MAROLI, SHIVABAGH, KADRI

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Mrs.madhwaraj, we are not fools. we all know what happend after B J P govt in Karnataka. Politcians like u change the party within a month for power and money. And please dont take the name of DHARMASTHALA, it got its own respect, believe and holyness. You are not fit for that.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Austin Santhosh,

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Udupi is now the favourite town of India's News Channels! Udupi's MLA's has hit the headlines during the last month and Udupi's MP in this month! For local channels, there are always some interesting news like Frog's Marriage, etc. What happened to Udupi? Udupi use to stand for Kanakadasa, Lord Krishna, Finest Vegetarian Hotels,best Education etc. etc. Gone are those days?

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Conald j baptist, mangalore/mumbai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Manorama deserves Padmabhushan for taking people of Udupi for grand royal ride

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rajesh Shetty, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Manorama has done right thing. BJP in Karnataka had snached away some MLA's from Congress and JDS. Now its Congress's turn.People have come to know the true colours of corrupt BJP MP's!!BJP has to pay for its own dirty games!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abulla Abbas, Kannar

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    I fully agree with Mr.Naveen, Udupi / UAE. It is correct, now it right time to bring a revolution by electing right candidates & dejecting useless politicians. It is good for our new generation.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Varun , Udupi

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Welcome to BJP goondas to Mrs. Manorama's residence for goondagiri. Please tell your family that you will not go back again to your home. Please remember Dharmendras film dialogue" Maa ka dood piya to saamne aawo......"

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Ram, Karkal

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Now it is the lady's turn to play dirty politics, am I right manoroma. I bet she did not think of india, she only thought of her family. because she was bought to power only when she contested from BJP. People should understand this.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Naveen, Udupi / UAE

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    The people who are complimenting Mrs. Manorama in this article are the same people who critisized C.M. Yeddy when some MLA's resigned from congress and JDS and joined BJP. For me both incidents are same and "SHAME" on democracy.

    Money played big roll in both the incidents not any ideology. We the people who follows South Canara politics from decades know Mrs. Manorama very well. So please don't compliment her for this shame incident. Please you wise South Canara people think above the party level.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • LAWRENCE, KATEEL/DUBAI

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Great work by Madwaraj!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sudarshan Shetty, Udupi/Dubai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Dear Manorama You have taken a rightful decision. Leaders should like you and take decision which benificial to the general public who elected the leaders and they pay tax to get right infrastature. I solute you. All the best in your future political career.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Abdul Rahim Kolnad, Healengady

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Congrats Manorama This is your good gecision......I am Proud o you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Bhaskar L.Poojary, Mumbai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    The way I understand its not the money, say 5 - 10 crores to pay her, to persuade or retain her in BJP,then it is not a big deal for Bellary Reddy brothers, who easily bought 5 MLA's in Karnataka, for few crores. Here, uneasy-ness in the company of RSS and highhanded ness of Yedyurappa, Sadananda Gowda and Co. is the major cause to her to desert BJP AT THIS CRUCIAL TIME.

    Its a slap on the face of state BJP, and now as a result, Sadananda Gowda's days are numbered as State BJP chief.Just mark my words....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • ROSHAN, UDUPI

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Greedy lady in need of money.Better you beg at any temple instead of invoking its name. Shame on you .You didnt do anything for your community or to the constituency.Get lost from politics. For money you may ready to do any thing. Shame on you and will have the curse of people who voted for you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Philip Richard P., Mumbai / Barkur

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Friends, Blood is thicker than water. Party affiliations may change overnight. All aware incuding Kodgi, Manorama finding it difficult to toe RSS line. It was mutual benefit, BJP and herself, 4 years ago prompted her to switch sides, now also the same, but small change in liue of BJP, its Congress.Its high time for BJP to introspect.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vishal D'Souza, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Mrs. Manorama in front of crores, even people will lose faith in GOD. People will remember GOD only when they are in trouble? Who knows you might have assured some amount to Sri Manjunatha of Dharmastala too for your lies & misadventure. Definitely your ( family's )political career will come to an end soon.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Guru, Udupi/Sharjah

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Mrs.Manorama Madhwaraj, now there is no point in screaming I have not done this for any monetary gain & also please stop using that name of sacred place for your cheap political acts. Public is aware & concious enough that what is your contribution for your constituency & also why you have voted on behalf of UPA, that is nothing other than by point of view for the MP ticket for forthcoming elections. Where was that awaarness while you were saying we do not have power shortage. Any way time is the reply for all deeds whether good or bad.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vishal D'Souza, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    This is all drama for gain. when the wind blows towards left they inclined towards left & vice versa. All is they want to gain from both sides, anyone can imagine here Mother BJP MP & son contesting Congress. Luckily he lost otherwise they (family) might have earned in both ways..! Do they have any ethics even if they are educated? Whether she will give employment for the people of udupi in her home? why she is protesting against the developement? All people should search other destinations like Gulf even now? People can earn & live peacefully only when there is development & industires. BJP made right thing by expelling her from the party , as there is much loyal support for BJP from public ecspecially in udupi district.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • rajesh, udupi / Dubai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    What Courage are people talking, she is the greedest political family in udupi, no doubt, she has a long time plan be it her son or herself, trying to groom her son, by abstaining, it is not called courage, BJP did not welcome her she begged her self in, even local muncipal councellors from udupi have done commendable work, leave the higher ups, little bit here and there in Malpe is not what to be proud of she has been a leader for long, but personal gains have always been her private misson, people might disagree with me, I have been a observer for long engouh, its time Mrs. Madwaraj, to relax and have a nice retired life. today dont mess up the BJP OR the congress, both have good leaders to lead let them lead and perform, you have served enough.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kiran , Muscat

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    fooling the voters, all these worst politics for their own benifits, either for money or for the seat,not for the people,people wont accept their justifications.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • girish, udupi/ California

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    What a joke after the UPA victory more black money is out. Some money is poured into stock markets, market up by 1500 points!!, some into swiss bank accounts. Average 3 crore multiplied by 30 MPs purchased, you do the mathematics. Manorama has done WISE descision by accepting few crores.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Vivke Mallya Nullipady , Solas Marine Services

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    BJP ge jai ,Congress ge Nanna Kai.OH cant trust todays politicians.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Kelvin Dsouza, Thottam/Dubai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    well done,Power shortage can only be solved, now by Nuclear Power Plants.we needed this Nuclear Treaty done long ago to advance our Country in all spheres.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • mkamath, udupi

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Shame on those who are switching the loyelty whichever party they belong to. If they don't agree with the party ideology to which they belong, then they must resign at that very moment of time without any pretext like interest of the country,interest of the region & interest of his/her siblings etc. The moral of this story of recent political switch over is like this. " One can tie the wayword pet dog at home , but not a stealing pet cat at Home". One can try this experiment if they have pets at their Home.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • javid, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Great work by Mrs Madvaraj, diffinately Congress will get both MLA and MP Seat from Udupi...All Know what is present MLA and BJP Govt doing in Karnataka.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Sunil Vaz, Mumbai/Muscat

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Congrats you have made us proud we need more like you who vote with your heart

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rakesh rai, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Welcome manorama into congress

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Srikanth Shetty,, Mangalore/Muscat

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    She is not voted for UPA nor for the nuclear bond, she is thinking about the next MP elections, she already knows that she won't get a MP seat from Udupi and this time Mr.Sunil is the MP candidate, so since she need the post, this time voted for congress nothing else. This all you can see in the coming MP's election time. These all are fooling the voters.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rolphy Almeida, Udupi/Bangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Dear Mrs. Madwaraj, I being Indian unreservedly appreciate your courage, to defy the BJP orders and stand neutral in this issue. This is a national issue and you stood for the nation. We need politicians who have no fear to raise their voice against the destroyers.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • SHARAN SALIAN, MANGALORE/BAHRAIN

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    There is no shortage of fools in our country only the thing that you should know how to fool them. Mrs. Manorama did it this time but how long?? You will never win a MLA seat next time forget MP!!

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Munna, Thottam

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Hats of to all those MP who put there Nation frist. Mr.Francis Rebello, is accusing some one in a way that he brought up Manorama and Pramod. I would love to see Rebello accused by the same....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Madhukar Bhandari, Udupi/Dubai

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Voter have voted you since you are a BJP candidate. Now you've deceived them for your personal gains. Shame on you.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Francis Rebello, Perampally / Udupi

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Who is Manorama trying to fool here? While protesting against Nagarjuna Power plant she kept saying there is no power shortage. And now suddenly she is saying India needs more power and we need nuclear plants!! Is it India needing more power or Manorama (and her son) needing to take care of crores of rupee loans after last assembly elections?

    It is open secret in Udupi that Manorama and Pramod spent crores of rupees in last election which they are trying to recover now. If she is trying to give some excuse for going against the whip it should be at least believable. How can people believe Manorama's stance when just few weeks back she was on the streets protesting Nagarjuna power plant and saying "there is no power shortage"!!??

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • royston, valencia/kuwait

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    congrats UPA.. u ve done it again.. hope u continue the great job going :).....

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Moosa Kunhi, Kakkinje/Dammam

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    India greater than Party.Manorama proved this in parliament.Best of Luck

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • Rupesh Lobo, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Its really nice to know a person representing Udupi - one of the most educated districts in the state choose the social gains above party interest. And to all those who are in BJP or in any other party..please learn to raise above the party politics. People from DK are smart and make rational decisions...they dont go by party politics. They vote based on people's credentials and Manorama is one among them.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse

  • M. M Alvares, Mangalore

    Thu, Jul 24 2008

    Mrs. Madwaraj, you deserve special compliments for your courage!! Don't run away from the political scene now, contest election as a Congress candidate or better support Pramod, who is young and surely a better and strong leader under the given conditions, to take on communal BJP, where you found uneasy to get along for the last 4 years, we are all with you, don't give up.

    DisAgree Agree Reply Report Abuse


Leave a Comment

Title: I did'nt Switch Loyalties for Monetory Considerations - Manorama



You have 2000 characters left.

Disclaimer:

Please write your correct name and email address. Kindly do not post any personal, abusive, defamatory, infringing, obscene, indecent, discriminatory or unlawful or similar comments. Daijiworld.com will not be responsible for any defamatory message posted under this article.

Please note that sending false messages to insult, defame, intimidate, mislead or deceive people or to intentionally cause public disorder is punishable under law. It is obligatory on Daijiworld to provide the IP address and other details of senders of such comments, to the authority concerned upon request.

Hence, sending offensive comments using daijiworld will be purely at your own risk, and in no way will Daijiworld.com be held responsible.